On the Blessed Inevitability of "Misreading"
Reader, attend to Sally Rooney:
Each reader, of course, encounters their own Ulysses: the one they create for themselves in the act of reading. Every reading of the novel yields a new text, one that has been pulled this way and that by the attention and inattention, the knowledge and ignorance, the likes and dislikes of the particular reader. And that reader is inevitably an entire person: a person with their own distinctive body, their own feelings, their own vocabulary, their own personal library of sensory memories and associations. These qualities are not unfortunate failures of objectivity: they are what make us capable of reading in the first place. Ulysses demands a reader who can respond as a human being, emotionally, intellectually, physically, erotically, even spiritually. And these demands are made on readers who are by necessity in no two cases the same. In our own particular bodies, reading with our eyes and our hands, with our own thoughts and feelings, we remake and reinterpret every text we encounter. Every interpretation has its weaknesses, its points of interest, its missing pieces. From this small limited partial perspective, embracing its smallness and limitations, I feel I need not worry so much about “misreading” Joyce. Every reading of Ulysses is a misreading, a faulty but revealing translation, a way of drawing the novel into new and perhaps unintended relationships. All that matters to me is finding a way to read the book that is interesting: that opens out instead of closing down.
This is, of course, why it can be such an illuminating experience to re-read a text you loved (or hated) at an earlier period in your life after some years have passed; it will inevitably offer up different things to the person you are than it did to the person you were. Each “misreading” helps us see a little more of the text and a little more of ourselves through the text.
This photo of Nick Cave awkwardly hugging Warren Ellis while holding a copy of Christian Wiman’s My Bright Abyss is so many of my favorite things in one place.
Dusk keeps coming earlier in St. Andrews. 26 days to the winter solstice.
It’s just not really Thanksgiving without homemade garmonbozia.
Currently reading: How To Think by Alan Jacobs 📚
Deeply insightful, & a pleasure to read. @ayjay, your choice of illustrative quotes from More and Luther first shocked, then sent both my wife and I into hysterics—all while perfectly demonstrating your point. Thank you!
I realize that I am pretty predictable, but…
I am absolutely loving this listening experience.
Not always serious, though. Sometimes friendly.
Photo credit: Felipe Krause Dornelles
Serious.
Photo credit: Felipe Krause Dornelles